Energy Is Not Speed, Relaxation Is Not Passivity: A Discussion of Energy in Relaxation

You often hear trainers and instructors calling out to their students, “More leg, more leg!” If I could identify the most common directive I hear in riding arenas and at show grounds, it's this.
Why is this? Because for most trainers, more leg equates to more forward, and well, forward is precisely the foundation of movement.
A willingness to go forward is one of the first pillars in training, and it's why I place it in the first phase of my training progression, The Contract. Without energy, movement cannot happen. The horse must first be willing to go forward, and the rider must be able to invite that energy without resistance.
What is often confusing to students, however, is the nature of forward movement. Riders frequently equate energy with speed. If the horse isn't sufficiently energetic, they ask him to go faster. If he is moving slowly, they assume he lacks energy.
But energy is not speed.
Speed is simply the rate at which the horse travels, the distance covered in a given amount of time. And there are certainly moments when we want speed. A horse galloping freely across a field can be a beautiful expression of energy and speed.
But when we speak of forward energy in classical riding, we mean something more than how quickly the horse is moving.
Energy is the capacity and readiness to perform work. It is the available power that allows the horse to move, balance, carry himself, and respond to the rider's requests. It can be expressed through forward movement, but it can also be contained, redirected, and organized.
A horse can be moving quite quickly and have very little useful, organized energy available for the work we're asking him to perform. Conversely, a horse can be moving very slowly, or almost in place, and possess an extraordinary amount of energy.
And this brings us to the missing element that must be present in the development and organization of energy: relaxation.
Energy Is Not Speed
You can see a particularly beautiful expression of this paradox in a correctly performed piaffe.
The horse is gathered like a spring, with a tremendous amount of potential energy available, and yet he trots in place. The tempo is measured, the expression is soft, and the horse appears quiet and attentive. There is no need for force or excessive pressure on the reins to contain him.
Imagine the organization of energy required to accomplish this! The horse is not lacking energy because he isn't traveling forward. Quite the opposite. He has developed the ability to carry and organize a remarkable amount of energy without allowing it to turn into unnecessary speed.
From this moment of highly organized activity, the horse can make a transition to walk, perhaps stretching down, without losing his composure or becoming tense.
Now contrast this with a horse performing something that resembles piaffe because he is excited or anxious. The energy builds, but so does the tension. The horse dances in place, yet seems ready to explode forward at any moment.
Watch the racehorses at the track being contained by their riders or pony horses. Sometimes you will see movements that superficially resemble piaffe. The horses are full of energy, but much of that energy is accompanied by excitement and tension. They may be moving their feet almost in place, but they are ready to take off.
The movements may look similar, but the quality of energy is quite different.
So, we need energy to perform work. But simply adding speed does not necessarily increase the useful energy available to us. In fact, when energy becomes disorganized, particularly when accompanied by tension, we often see unnecessary acceleration.
This is not to say that speed itself creates tension. A horse can gallop freely and remain beautifully relaxed. The important distinction is whether the energy is available to the horse and rider, or whether they are being carried along by it.
The goal is not simply to generate more energy, but to develop the ability to organize and regulate it.
And we cannot do this successfully without relaxation.
Relaxation Is Not Passivity
Now, there is a kind of relaxation that is really lethargy, or passivity. That is not what we mean when we speak about relaxation in training.
Imagine a person collapsed on the couch, the classic couch potato. There isn't usually much energy available for that person to spring up and go do the dishes! They may appear relaxed, but they are hardly in a state of readiness for activity.
This is not the relaxation we're looking for in our horses, or in ourselves.
Relaxation does not mean the absence of muscular tone. It doesn't mean the horse is physically slack, mentally disengaged, or simply going along without participating.
Nor does it mean that the rider becomes passive, abandoning posture, coordination, or attention.
The muscles must be ready for work, and indeed, the muscles are already working to maintain posture, balance, and organization. But they must be free of unnecessary tension.
Additionally, the mind is present not absent.
The horse is attentive, and ready to respond. He may be standing quietly, or walking in an easy rhythm, yet the energy required for something as demanding as a piaffe is potentially available to him.
He is quiet in his mind, but ready.
And this is an important distinction. Relaxation is not the absence of effort. It is the absence of unnecessary tension within effort.
Consider the rider who is constantly applying more leg to create energy. Often the rider begins to work harder, tightening the seat, bracing through the back, or driving with the legs. The horse may respond by moving faster, but not necessarily with better balance or greater freedom.
Sometimes both horse and rider are expending a tremendous amount of effort, building more tension without accomplishing very much.
The rider must also learn to develop energy in relaxation. We must be sufficiently organized in our own bodies to communicate effectively, while remaining supple enough to follow the horse's movement. We must be attentive without becoming anxious, active without becoming forceful.
The rider's relaxation, like the horse's, is not passivity.
Energy in Relaxation
I would say that this state, energy in relaxation, is one of the most fundamental qualities we must develop for excellent training throughout our journey.
Both people and horses have to learn it, experience it, and become accustomed to it.
And it is not easy.
Often we find ourselves at one extreme or the other. There is anxious or nervous energy, in which movement is accompanied by tension and hurry. Or there is apathetic, couch-potato relaxation, in which there is little readiness or willingness to participate.
What we are looking for is something quite different: energy that is readily available, yet exists within a state of physical and mental relaxation.
And this quality is not something we establish once, early in training, and then leave behind as we move on to more sophisticated work.
It is both a prerequisite for good training and a quality that must continually be refined.
In the first phase of my Classical Riding Roadmap, Contract, we establish the horse's willingness to go forward, to accept our invitations without fear or unnecessary resistance.
In the second phase, Dance, we begin to organize this energy through rhythm, tempo, balance, and coordination. The horse and rider learn to move together, maintaining relaxation while developing the energy necessary for increasingly demanding work.
As we progress through Mirror, Flame, Whisper, and ultimately Centaur, the requirements become more sophisticated. We develop greater awareness of our physical organization, more power, greater collection, and increasingly subtle communication.
But we must never sacrifice the essential qualities we began developing in the earliest stages.
Indeed, the greater the demands of training, the more important energy in relaxation becomes.
The horse performing piaffe with extraordinary power and softness is demonstrating a highly developed expression of the same fundamental quality we seek in the young horse learning to walk forward willingly and quietly.
And the rider who appears almost motionless while communicating with extraordinary precision has developed a similar capacity in themselves.
The apparent simplicity of the result can conceal the sophistication of the work required to achieve it.
What Does This Mean for Our Daily Riding?
The next time you find yourself asking your horse for more energy, consider what you're actually asking him to do.
Do you want him to go faster? Or do you want him to become more responsive, more attentive, and better able to organize his movement?
If he speeds up, has he actually developed more useful energy, or has he simply changed his tempo?
And when your horse feels relaxed, ask yourself whether he is truly relaxed or merely passive. Is he still attentive and ready to respond? Does he maintain his balance and muscular tone? Is the energy available when you ask for it?
Consider these same questions about yourself as a rider.
Are you creating unnecessary tension in your effort to produce more energy? Are you able to remain relaxed without losing your posture, attention, or ability to communicate?
Learning to recognize these distinctions is an important part of developing our judgment as riders.
I believe that when horse and rider begin to develop this balance between energy and relaxation, they discover that work becomes less tiring. There is less energy wasted through unnecessary tension, more energy available for the work itself, and greater possibilities for balance and precision.
And perhaps most importantly, there is a greater sense of harmony between horse and rider.
Energy is not speed. Relaxation is not passivity.
The art lies in learning to cultivate one without sacrificing the other.
And that is a journey that begins with our very first conversations with the horse and continues throughout the entire development of classical riding.
Explore the Six Phases of Classical Riding
The six phases referenced in this article—Contract, Dance, Mirror, Flame, Whisper, and Centaur—are part of A Classical Riding Roadmap, a developmental framework for understanding the education of both horse and rider.
If you'd like to explore this journey more deeply, I invite you to download my complimentary guide, The Classical Riding Journey: An Introduction to the Roadmap.




Comments